I think I agree with your sentiments. A rematch isn't really that great a storyline, especially when it's a perennial great team vs a somewhat oafish team. I feel like it could have been an interesting story if there had been a little more time between. We get reminded yearly about the Tyree catch, and we get reminded yearly about how Brady's won three but hasn't been to the podium since.

Let's just have a little review of the storylines over the past few years:

• Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Green Bay Packers - Can the Steelers add a 7th Lombardi to their collection? Did Green Bay make the right choice by going with Aaron Rodgers over Favre?
• Indianapolis Colts vs. New Orleans Saints - Can Peyton Manning put his critics to rest by getting closer to the number of rings that Tom Brady has? Can New Orleans drop their old moniker of the Aints and cement themselves as an elite football team?
• Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Arizona Cardinals - Can the Steelers make history as the first team to get 6 Vince Lombardi Trophies? Can Kurt Warner find redemption in the Super Bowl by leading the Cardinals to a championship in their first appearance?
• New England Patriots vs. New York Giants - Can New England finally put to rest all the talk of the 72 Dolphins and be the first Undefeated Super Bowl winners since the institution of a 16 game season? Can the Giants lead by Eli Manning stop the juggernaut that is Tom Brady and the Patriots offense?
• Indianapolis Colts vs. Chicago Bears - Two time league MVP Peyton Manning finally got the monkey off his back, can he and Marvin Harrison get the championship that has eluded them for so many years? Can the Bears finally win the Lombardi again after such a long drought from the infamous Super Bowl Shuffle?
• Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Seattle Seahawks - Can the Pittsburgh Steelers win a Super Bowl for the first time since the Steel Curtain team with Terry Bradshaw and show they're as good as the 49ers and Cowboys? Can the Seahawks win the big game in their first ever appearance?
• New England Patriots vs. Philadelphia Eagles - Can the Patriots win Back to Back Super Bowls and cement themselves as a Dynasty? Can the Philadelphia Eagles win their first championship in the Super Bowl Era in their first appearance since Super Bowl XV?
• New England Patriots vs. Carolina Panthers - Can the Patriots prove the 2001 Super Bowl wasn't a fluke and win another Super Bowl just two years after the first? Can the Carolina Panthers, who went 1-15 in the 2000 season, find redemption by winning the Super Bowl two years later?
• Oakland Raiders vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Can Jon Gruden's Buccaneers defeat the team that traded him away at the beginning of the season?
• New England Patriots vs. St. Louis Rams - Despite losing star quarterback Drew Bledsoe to injury early in the season, the Patriots rallied behind an unknown 6th round draft named Tom Brady. Can they beat two time NFL MVP Kurt Warner and the Greatest Show On Turf?